Showing posts with label 529. Show all posts
Showing posts with label 529. Show all posts

Monday, November 9, 2026

Trump Accounts (530A) vs. 529 Plans: A Lawyer's Perspective


A recent New York Times article advises that the new Trump Accounts, formally Section 530A accounts, are worth opening primarily to capture free government and philanthropic seed money. The IRS reports in IR-2026-129 that nearly 70 million accounts are open, and 27 million have received funds. The seed money is real: the federal government deposits $1,000 for each child born from 2025 through 2028. Clients are asking whether to fund these accounts for children and grandchildren. From an elder law and estate planning perspective, the more important questions are who controls the account and what happens when someone dies.

The Account Belongs to the Child

Under Revenue Procedure 2026-25, a Trump Account is a traditional IRA established for an eligible child, and the child is treated as its owner. Parents or guardians act as custodians until the child turns 18. Distributions are generally barred until January 1 of the year the child turns 18, and contributions are not deductible. Under § 530A, contributions other than the exempt ones, such as the federal seed deposit and certain charitable contributions, are capped at $5,000 a year. That limit is aggregate: it applies to all non-exempt contributions to the child's single account combined, whoever makes them, and it is not a per-donor limit. Parents, grandparents, aunts, uncles, and friends share one $5,000 allowance.

This is the opposite of a 529 plan, and the difference drives everything below. A grandparent who opens a 529 plan owns it, keeps control, can change the beneficiary, and can name a successor owner. A grandparent who contributes to a child's Trump Account makes a completed gift to the child and keeps nothing: no control, no ability to take it back, and no successor owner to name.

Who May Open the Account, and Where Grandparents Fit

A grandparent usually cannot open the account. Under the proposed regulations, the person who may make the election to open, or claim, an account follows a priority order: generally a legal guardian first, then a parent, then an adult sibling, then a grandparent, with limited additional options in some circumstances, such as certain child-welfare agencies. A grandparent generally cannot open or claim an account if a higher-priority person, a parent or guardian, is available. That is not a technicality. For a grandchild born before 2025, the election includes a sworn statement that no higher-priority person is available, and the guidance does not define "available." A grandparent who signs it carelessly risks an invalid election and a false statement made under penalty of perjury.

Once the account exists, the rules are friendlier. Grandparents, other relatives, employers, and philanthropic sources may contribute, subject to the annual limit, but they do not open a second account. Treasury has also implemented automatic enrollment for many eligible children, so a parent or guardian typically claims and activates the auto-created account. That means the practical advice to a grandparent is usually to ask the parents whether an account already exists and to contribute to it, not to open one. Because the temporary regulations issued September 30 replaced the earlier proposals, confirm the current priority rules before anyone signs an election.

Quick Comparison: 529 Plans and 530A Accounts

529 plans remain the superior dedicated education savings tool for most families. A 530A account functions more like a starter retirement account for a child:
  • Tax Treatment: A 529 plan offers tax-free growth and tax-free withdrawals for qualified education expenses. A 530A account is a traditional, not Roth, IRA. Growth is tax-deferred, but withdrawals are taxed under IRA rules, and the account is not tailored to education expenses.
  • Main Attractions: The main current attractions of a 530A account are the $1,000 federal seed deposit for children born 2025 through 2028 and additional philanthropic contributions. A 529 plan offers no seed deposit, but it is built for the goal most families actually have.
  • Contribution Limits: 529 plans allow high contributions. Contributions to a 530A account are limited to $5,000 a year in the aggregate from all non-exempt sources, indexed after 2027.
  • Flexibility: A 529 owner can change the beneficiary and decide when and how the money is used. A 530A account is tied to the one child it was opened for.
  • Who Owns It: A 529 plan belongs to whoever opens it, so a grandparent or parent keeps control. A 530A account belongs to the child, and the grandparent has no control.
  • Estate Planning Coordination: A 529 plan offers stronger protection and planning options when coordinated with trusts and successor-owner designations. A 530A account cannot be held in a trust and has no successor owner, because the child is the owner.
In short, take the free seed money, but do not let it displace a 529 plan for a family whose goal is education, or for a grandparent who wants to keep control of the money.

Gift Tax and the Safe Harbor

Revenue Procedure 2026-25 gives donors a safe harbor. Qualifying cash contributions made before the child turns 18 are treated as completed gifts that are not gifts of future interests, so the annual exclusion applies ($19,000 per recipient for 2026). The total of everything a donor gives that child in the year must stay within the exclusion, and the donor must not file a Form 709 for the year for any purpose. A grandparent who also funds a 529 plan or pays tuition directly needs to count the account contribution along with every other gift to the same grandchild.

What Happens When Someone Dies

  • If the Person Who Contributed Dies: Nothing happens to the account, because the gift was complete. The account does not depend on the person's will or trust, and there is nothing to retitle or leave to anyone. That simplicity is a benefit, but it also means the donor has no way to protect the money if the family's circumstances change.
  • If the Child Dies Before the Year the Child Turns 18: Under § 530A(d)(6), the account stops being a Trump Account, and the distribution restriction no longer applies. The fair market value, less the child's basis, is taxed as ordinary income to the person who receives it, or to the child's final return if the estate receives it. Basis excludes the federal seed deposit and charitable contributions, so those dollars are fully taxable. I could not find clear guidance on who may sign a beneficiary designation for a young child or what the default is if none is made. The responsible party manages certain administrative matters during the growth period, but death-benefit designations appear to be left to the custodian’s account agreement and ordinary IRA rules once the account ceases to be a Trump Account. Ask the trustee before assuming anything.
  • If a Parent Dies: The account is the child's, but a minor needs an adult to act for the child. There does not appear to be an automatic successor-custodian rule comparable to some state UTMA statutes, so the practical protection is the guardian nomination in the parents' plan. Parents should name a guardian for minor children, and the family should plan for someone to manage the account and stay on top of its reporting.
  • After the Child Turns 18: The account becomes the child's own traditional IRA, and an eighteen-year-old controls it. No trustee or successor owner stands between the child and the money. Ordinary IRA rules apply, including the 10 percent additional tax on early distributions unless an exception applies, taxation of withdrawals that includes any basis (the distribution rules apply to a Trump Account separately from the child's other IRAs), and, eventually, required minimum distributions. Whether a particular grandchild should have that control is a family question to settle before the contribution, not after.

The rules are still moving. Treasury and the IRS issued temporary regulations on September 30, 2026, together with related proposed rules. They address how accounts are established, automatic enrollment, and qualified general contributions, and comments are due November 30, 2026. Administration details and beneficiary designations can still change, so confirm the current rules before relying on any of this.

Special Needs and Disability Benefits

For a grandchild who receives, or may later receive, SSI, the account needs planning. SSA's POMS instruction SI 01120.250, as summarized by Empire Justice, excludes the account from income and resources until January 1 of the year the child turns 18. After that, it can count. The statute allows a tax-free transfer of the entire balance to an ABLE account in the calendar year the child turns 17. Because the child owns the account, a special needs trust cannot hold a Trump Account, so a family with a disabled grandchild should treat these accounts as a bridge to an ABLE account and calendar the transfer.

The Elder Law Issue Most Articles Skip

A grandparent's contribution is a gift. For a client who may need long-term care within five years, it is a transfer for less than fair market value that can matter under the Medicaid look-back, even if it comes within the gift tax exclusion. A well-documented, modest annual gift may be reasonable for a healthy client. For a client with declining health, weigh the same gift against the client's care plan, not because seed money is available.

What Clients Should Consider

  • Decide Who Gets Control: If a grandchild is not ready to control an IRA at 18, a 529 plan that the grandparent owns, or a trust, may fit better than a Trump Account.
  • Keep the Gifts Within the Safe Harbor: Contribute cash, count every gift to that grandchild for the year, and avoid filing a Form 709 where the safe harbor applies.
  • Coordinate With Guardianship Nominations: Parents should name guardians for minor children so that someone has clear authority over the child's accounts.
  • Plan for Disability Benefits: If SSI is a possibility, calendar the ABLE transfer for the year the child turns 17.
  • Check the Long-Term Care Picture: Before an older client gives anything, look at the client's own health, the look-back, and the care plan.
  • Do Not Promise Creditor Protection: Section 530A does not create any special federal creditor protection for these accounts, so do not assume a child's account is shielded from creditors.  State law governs general creditors' reach.
Conclusion

Take the free seed money, and understand what you are accepting. A Trump Account is a child's IRA, not a parent or grandparent's estate planning tool. It works as a modest supplement. It does not replace a 529 plan, and for a grandparent who wants to keep control, it is not a substitute. Decide whether to fund it with the whole plan in view: the donor's circumstances, the family's guardianship nominations, and the donor's own care.

Sunday, September 28, 2014

Achieving a Better Life Experience (ABLE) Act Would Create Tax-free Accounts for the Disabled

Sara Wolff (center) is calling on Congress to allow disabled
 Americans to save and still receive benefits like
 Social Security Disability Insurance payments and Medicaid.
Many families struggle with planning for the future of a child with severe disabilities. While they are able to save for the educational needs of their other children through “529” college tuition plans, these plans do not fit well the needs of a child with severe disabilities.  The disabled child may, now, or in adulthood, need the long term services and supports of the Medicaid program and/or the income assistance of the Supplemental Security Income (SSI) program.  Since the child may live for many decades beyond the ability of the parents to supplement the services they receive through Medicaid, most parents recognize the need for saving and securing funds for the child.  Others want to ensure the financial security of a disabled child who has a level of disability required for Medicaid eligibility, but for now, is managing to function without the use of those benefits. Still others want to ensure that their family member can exercise control over the funds in the account without endangering the Medicaid and SSI benefits on which they may rely.

Although Supplemental Needs Trusts and/or Wholly Discretionary Trusts for Special Needs offer a savings solution, many families have found it too expensive to establish a trust which meets the requirements of the Medicaid and SSI programs.  While many attorneys will prepare these for reduced fees for those in need, it is not uncommon to pay five to ten thousand dollars for these solutions.  The ABLE Act (S.313 / H.R.647) would give individuals with disabilities and their families access to accounts that would allow individual choice and control while protecting eligibility for Medicaid, SSI, and other important federal benefits for people with disabilities.

The Senate Finance subcommittee on taxation and IRS oversight may have never heard testimony from someone quite like Sara Wolff.  Ms. Wolff, 31, was born with Down syndrome, but that hasn’t stopped her from becoming involved in politics. She testified before the subcommittee on the Achieving a Better Life Experience (ABLE) Act, which would create tax-free savings accounts for those with disabilities. Earlier this year, she wrote a change.org petition calling on Congress to pass the ABLE Act. The petition garnered more than 250,000 online signatures.

“Just because I have Down syndrome, that shouldn’t hold me back from achieving my full potential in life,” Ms. Wolff of Moscow, Pa., said in a statement. “I can work a full-time job, be a productive member of society, and pay taxes – but because of outdated laws placed on individuals with disabilities, we hold people like me back in life.”

Ms Wolf is also a board member of the National Down Syndrome Society (NDSS), which is championing the bipartisan legislation. The Senate bill is sponsored by Sen. Robert Casey, Pennsylvania Democrat, and Sen. Richard Burr, North Carolina Republican.  Support for the House bill is being led by Rep. Ander Crenshaw, Florida Republican; Rep. Cathy McMorris Rodgers, Washington Republican; Rep. Pete Sessions, Texas Republican; and Rep. Chris Van Hollen, Maryland Democrat.

“The bill aims to ease financial strains faced by individuals with disabilities by making tax-free savings accounts available to cover qualified expenses such as education, housing and transportation,” said an NDSS statement.

Ms. McMorris Rodgers, whose seven-year-old son Cole has Down syndrome, called on Congress to “advance this crucial legislation.”  “As the mom of a son with Down syndrome, I see firsthand how federal policies limit—not expand— opportunities for those with disabilities.  And the ABLE Act will change that,” said Ms. McMorris Rodgers in a statement. “It will make sure that Cole — and the millions like him who have special needs — will be able to save for their futures and reach their full potential.”

The ABLE Act  has 74 Senate co-sponsors, including Senate Majority Leader Harry Reid and GOP Minority Leader Mitch McConnell.  “Passing this landmark legislation will go a long way to help people with Down syndrome and other disabilities realize and achieve their own hopes, dreams and aspirations,” NDSS Vice President of Advocacy and Affiliate Relations Sara Hart Weir said in a statement.

Members of the U.S. Senate said Friday, September 26th, that they have an agreement that will allow the Achieving a Better Life Experience, or ABLE, Act to proceed to the full Congress.  The bill’s chief sponsors and leaders of the Senate’s Committee on Finance said in a joint statement that they expect the legislation to be considered when Congress returns to Washington in November.

Under the measure, people with disabilities would be able to create special accounts at any financial institution where they could deposit up to $14,000 annually. The ABLE accounts could accrue up to $100,000 in savings without risking an individual’s eligibility for government benefits like Social Security. What’s more, Medicaid coverage could be retained no matter how much money is deposited in the proposed accounts.
Modeled after the popular 529 college savings plans, funds deposited in ABLE accounts could be used to pay for education, health care, transportation, housing and other expenses. Interest earned on savings within the accounts would be tax-free.
The ABLE Act has been under consideration in Congress since 2006.  It is time that this proposal was enacted into law.
If you want to follow this legislation, Autism Speaks will do that for you by clicking here.  


Tuesday, April 13, 2010

Noteworthy Changes to Coverdell Accounts Demand Consideration

Families interested in opening a Coverdell Education Savings Account this year for college savings should consider doing so before April 15. That would allow them to invest as much as $4,000 in one of these tax-advantaged accounts this year—twice the maximum for annual contributions—since money deposited before April 15 can be counted against the previous year's limit.

But families planning to use a Coverdell account to pay for pre-college education expenses should think twice about opening or contributing to an account this year. Starting next year, withdrawals from Coverdells to pay expenses from kindergarten through 12th grade will no longer be tax-free, unless Congress acts to extend that benefit, which is far from certain.

Another prospective rule change would lower the limit on annual contributions to $500 starting next year, making Coverdells less useful for college savings. Already, the $2,000 limit has made Coverdells much less popular than 529 college-savings plans, which offer similar tax benefits for college costs and a roughly $300,000 limit on contributions overall. But even some people who are putting away more than $2,000 a year for college have included Coverdells in their savings plans, because Coverdells offer a greater range of investment options than 529 plans, and more freedom to switch investments.

Another benefit that could expire at year's end is the ability of an investor to claim a Hope or Lifetime Learning tax credit for education in the same year they use Coverdell funds, as long as the tax credit and Coverdell money aren't used for the same expense. For example, an investor can take a tax credit for tuition in the same year s/he is using Coverdell money for books.  This benefit is scheduled to sunset at the end of this year,  resulting in the two tax benefits becoming mutually exclusive.