Filial Responsibility Laws Complicate Estate and Financial Planning

Warning of the challenges created by state filial responsibility laws, Jamie Hopkins, co-director of the New York Life Center for Retirement Income at the American College of Financial Services, has penned an excellent article for advisers entitled,  Family-Responsibility Laws Could Cost Your Clients: Be Aware of Laws Aiming to hold Family Members Financially Responsible for Other Family Members.

The article explains filial responsibility laws which "aim to hold family members financially responsible for other family members," by providing that "children can be held responsible for their mother and father’s nursing-home costs."   The article warns that although these laws have not been applied often because of the prevalence of social programs like Social Security, Medicare, and Medicaid, "with more and more retirees unable to meet their expenses, some providers have turned to filial laws for payment of debts."  

The article continues:

"The most widely cited recent application of filial law is 2012’s Pennsylvania case, Health Care & Retirement Corporation of America v. Pittas, in which the court held that a son was liable for a $93,000 nursing-home bill owed by his mom.

Since 2012, some care facilities have begun using filial laws to entice children of nursing-home residents to make payments or to ensure that the Medicaid application process is properly completed. However, there has not yet been a major uptick in lawsuits applying filial laws to recover unpaid bills.

Perhaps more interesting than the Pittas case is Eori v. Eori, in which the Superior Court of Pennsylvania upheld a monthly filial-support obligation of $400 from one brother to another in order to pay for long-term-care support for their seriously ill mother. The plaintiff son, who himself provided a lot of the care at home, was able to demonstrate that his mother could not pay all of her costs and needed financial assistance.

This case helps show the far-reaching potential of filial-support laws, as siblings can be required to help support their parents even if they are not in a nursing home or other professional facility.

This blog last warned about filial responsibility in the article Filial Responsibility Laws Lead to Chaos.  Many conclude that it is not a question of whether filial responsibility laws will find widespread application to long term care cases, it is a question of when.

To read more about filial responsibility, go here,  go here, here, here, here, and here.