Missouri Receives a Near Failing "D" on Nursing Home Report Card

Families for Better Care ("FBC"), recently  published its state-by-state nursing home report card. Missouri received  a near failing "D" grade, ranking thirty-ninth (39th) among the fifty states. The only bright news is that current ranking represents an increase in Missouri's relative ranking, up from  fortieth last year, and an improvement to Missouri's near failing "D" grade this year from a failing "F" last year. 

FBC scores, ranks, and grades states on eight different federal quality measures ranging from the number of caregiver hours residents received on a given day to the percentage of nursing homes cited severe deficiencies. The Report Cards include information from the newly revamped Nursing Home Compare reporting, requiring nursing homes to prove staffing levels, a sharp departure from previous administrations that accepted, without proof, representations from nursing homes regarding sufficiency of staffing.  More than one-third of nursing homes saw CMS ratings drop under the new, more deliberate, and more reliable system.

Regarding the Missouri's ranking, the Report Card noted:

• Missouri’s nursing home care climbed eight spots and moved up one full letter grade; ranking No. 39 overall and posting the state’s first non-failing grade in report card history.
• Missouri scored failing or below average grades in 5 of 8 nursing home quality measures.
• Less than 40 percent of Missouri’s nursing homes provide above average direct care staffing, resulting in a high percentage of understaffed homes.
• Missouri nursing home’s professional nursing services are among the most depleted in the nation as facilities provide fewer than 81 minutes of licensed nursing care per resident daily.
• Severe deficiencies in Missouri’s nursing homes climbed higher following the previous reporting period’s decline.
• Despite Missouri’s glaringly high percentage of facilities with deficiencies, the state’s ombudsmen verified 55 percent fewer registered complaints—pushing the state’s ranking into this year’s Top 10 states for this category.
• Missouri’s nursing home care ranks at the bottom of the Central Plains Region

Families for Better Care, Inc., is a Texas-based nursing home resident advocacy group dedicated to creating public awareness of the conditions in our nation’s nursing homes and other long-term care settings and developing effective solutions for improving quality of life and care.

“This year’s nursing home report card exposed an alarming trend that should serve as a wake-up call for us all,” said Brian Lee, Families for Better Care’s executive director. “Nursing home inspection ratings have soured.”

According to survey data collected by federal and state governments, fewer than 30 percent of nursing homes were capable of scoring an above average inspection rating, that’s nearly a 15 percent decline since the last reporting period.

“America’s nursing home care is worsening,” Lee exclaimed. “Erratic inspection performance is, by and large, traceable to a singular reason, the failure by so many nursing home operators to hire enough staff to safely care for residents.”

While Families for Better Care has repeatedly warned that nursing home staffing shortfalls are a grievous problem, the organization is calling for a new solution, one that the nursing home industry should welcome and would be embraced by residents and their families.

“The best way to heal America’s nursing homes is to appropriate additional funding to be used solely for hiring more staff,” Lee stated. “No more excuses, no more threats, no more scare tactics from lobbyists, politicians, operators—or anyone else for that matter—it’s time to do what’s right and stop the infliction of our loved ones with unnecessary injury or harm because of negligent policy making.”

According to the report’s findings, the majority of nursing homes (54 percent) were incapable of scoring an above average staffing rating. Residents received just 2 hours and 33 minutes of direct care daily—an average that’s unchanged from the previous report card. Nearly every state—with the exception of Alaska, the District of Columbia, and New Mexico—suffered a net loss in the percentage of nursing homes with above average staffing levels over the past three report cards.

“Before any checks are written to nursing homes, a rock solid staffing standard must accompany any new funding; otherwise, taxpayer monies could end up being diverted to subsidize the lifestyles of the rich and not-so-famous instead of getting back to the residents and their care,” Lee stated. “Too many nursing homes have demonstrated an unfaithfulness in self-governing their staffing levels to safely care for residents, so it’s time we help them out a little, as a nation, by federally mandating the most stringent staffing requirement that leaves no loopholes through which violators could squeeze.”

 As for the state’s nursing home rankings, the states highly rated in past report cards, once again, dominated the top spots while the chronic underachievers continued to disappoint.

This year’s top nursing home states were Hawaii, Delaware and Alaska while Texas, North Carolina, and Illinois scraped the bottom of the barrel. States with the biggest gains in overall ranking were New York (↑20), Mississippi (↑17), and Nevada (↑14) while Vermont (↓27), Massachusetts (↓24), and Arkansas suffered the biggest losses.

Three of the last report card’s best nursing home states slid out of the top ten, including Vermont, which plunged from No. 3 to No. 31 overall. The remaining states were New Hampshire (down from No. 2 to No. 11) and Florida (falling seven spots from No. 6 to No. 13).

Other key findings included:

• 500,000 elderly living in dangerous conditions—Nearly half-a-million elderly nursing home residents are living in facilities that tolerate below average staffing scores.
• Abuse and neglect vexes nursing home quality—1 in 5 nursing homes abused, neglected, or mistreated residents in almost half of all states for the second consecutive report card.
• States that are downright awful—Texas, Illinois, New Mexico, Michigan, Oklahoma, Louisiana, and Indiana consistently linger at, or near, the bottom in state nursing home care, scoring failing grades in every nursing home report card.

Families for Better Care argues that America desperately needs a nursing home cultural transformation, and the best way for that to happen is for nursing homes to saturate facility hallways with a brigade of well-trained frontline caregivers.

“Nursing home staffing levels must be ratcheted up if care is ever going to improve,” said Lee. “Since nursing homes rely so heavily on federal and state reimbursements, it’s incumbent upon us to pull up our bootstraps and find a way to inject much needed staffing currency as soon as possible.”


Readers of this blog should not be, and probably are not, shocked by either the report card grades, or the news that nursing home quality is generally worsening. These are compelling, but hardly new, reasons for implementing an Aging in Place plan.  If you haven't already, ask to attend an Aging in Place workshop.  

More:

State's [Pennsylvania] Failing Grade for Nursing Home Care is Unconscionable
Nursing Home Care Declines in Florida
Illinois Nursing Homes Rank Third Worst in the Country
Texas Ranked Last on 2019 Nursing Home Report Card
Delaware Ranked No. 2 on Nursing Home Report Card
Hawaii Grabs Nursing Home Report Card's Top Spot
Strong Staffing Boosts Alaska To No. 3 On 2019 Nursing Home Report Card
Rhode Island Slips to No. 4 On 2019 Nursing Home Report Card
Utah Ranks No. 5 On 2019 Nursing Home Report Card
Idaho Ranks No. 6 in 2019 Nursing Home Report Card
Arizona Ranked No. 7 on 2019 Nursing Home Report Card
Washington D.C. Surges To No. 8 On 2019 Nursing Home Report Card
Maine Drops to No. 9 on 2019 Nursing Home Report Card
North Carolina Drops to Second Worst in Nursing Home Quality