Little Noticed Provision in Trump Executive Order Allows Seniors to Opt Out of Medicare

Seniors are now permitted to opt out of Medicare.  A little-noticed section of a longer Executive Order on Medicare issued last November by President Trump directed the Secretary of Health and Human Services (HHS) to “revise current rules or policies to preserve the Social Security retirement insurance benefits of seniors who choose not to receive benefits under Medicare Part A.” (E.O. 13890, Sec. 11). The order took effect on April 3, 2020, but there appear to be no new proposed rules. 

You may wonder, "why?"  During President Obama’s administration, three retired federal employees – among them former Republican House Majority Leader Dick Armey -- sued the federal government because they wanted to drop their Medicare Part A coverage without losing Social Security benefits. They claimed participation in Medicare threatened their coverage under the Federal Employees Health Benefit (FEHB) program.

A U.S. district court judge dismissed the case in March 2011, a decision that was upheld the following year by a three-judge panel of the U.S. Court of Appeals for the District of Columbia, with then-judge Brett Kavanaugh writing for the majority that the federal statute offers the plaintiffs no path to disclaim their legal entitlement to Medicare Part A benefits.  The U.S. Supreme Court declined to review the decision.   

Although there exist no implementing rules, presumably anyone can now drop Medicare coverage without it affecting their Social Security retirement benefit.   John Kraus, one of the plaintiffs in the original suit, explained to ElderLawAnswers that “[t]here isn't any law, statute, or regulation that memorializes in the U.S. Code this linkage of the two programs. It is only found in the Social Security Administration's (SSA) Program Operations Manual System (POMS).”

When asked why he and his fellow plaintiffs wanted to separate from Medicare, Kraus explained that  the reasons

“are several.  The foremost is that one enrolled in Medicare cannot have a High Deductible Health Plan with a Health Savings Account. Secondly, for FEHB participants, their coverage becomes secondary to Medicare, without a premium reduction for FEHB coverage. Third, there is the issue of Medicare solvency, which could be a serious consideration in the near future. Lastly, there is the consideration of reduced choice and availability of health care providers because they are either leaving the Medicare program or not accepting additional Medicare recipients as new patients.”

Judith Stein, executive director of the Center for Medicare Advocacy, contends that allowing people to drop Medicare Part A would only weaken the program.  “We do not support allowing people to opt out of Part A,” Stein told ElderLawAnswers.  “[It’s] not good for Medicare in general, and not allowed by courts – to date.”