Study Shows Some Hospitals Steering Patients Away from Nursing Homes

Put YOU back in your plan!

Good news is on the horizon for seniors and their families hoping to Age in Place, i.e., avoid unnecessary institutional care.  There is evidence the underlying health care system is reforming to embrace Aging in Place preference for non-institutional care.  According to an article  published in McKnights Long Term Care News, hospitals participating in bundled payment efforts are actively reducing the use of skilled nursing care! The evidence comes in the form of a new study out of the University of Pennsylvania, published Monday in Health Affairs.

Skilled care is a big driver of cost growth and variation in Medicare, the authors note. In 2015 alone, about twenty percent (20%) of Medicare fee-for-service hospital admissions went to a Skilled Nursing Facility (SNF), despite scant evidence that this is the optimal post-acute setting, or that a nursing home helps improve quality, Penn researchers wrote.  Of course, that is no surprise to those of us in the "Aging in Place: community.  Long have advocates decried the obvious negative physical, mental, and  and emotional health outcomes so often incident to and consequence of institutional care, and particularly unnecessary or avoidable institutionalization.   

Motivated primarily by concerns for cost growth and variation, however, the Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services (CMS) has finally arrived at the same destination.  CMS has undertaken both the Bundled Payments for Care Improvement initiative and the Comprehensive Care for Joint Replacement model in an effort to eradicate some of that cost variation. Wanting to better understand how hospitals are navigating these waters, researchers interviewed leaders at twenty-two (22) institutions taking part in those two CMS bundled pay efforts.

"It's clear from the results that hospitals are looking to reduce SNF use," said Jane Zhu, lead author and a national clinician scholar and fellow in the Division of General Internal Medicine at Penn's Perelman School of Medicine.  She explained:   

“For the past couple of decades, we've had a persistent increase in SNF utilization across the country, but it's still very unclear what the benefit ultimately is for patients, and what the optimal post-acute setting is,” she told McKnight's. “As bundled payment incentives force hospitals to think along the lines of total cost of care, they're starting to see that, for certain patients, skilled nursing facilities offer no greater benefit and are more expensive than other venues.”

Often, hospitals are reducing SNF referrals by using risk-stratification tools, better educating patients, providing care support at home, and better linking up with home health agencies to smooth out any discharge hiccups.  Of course, patient choice and directive, not mentioned by the researchers or McKnights may also be contributing to reduced SNF utilization.

Other hospitals, meanwhile, are strengthening bonds with nursing homes, researchers found. Fifteen institutions formed networks of preferred SNFs, aiming to exert influence over cost and quality. Typical tactics found included linking electronic medical records, embedding a hospital provider in the nursing home and hiring dedicated care coordination staffers.  Most often, hospitals are partnering with SNFs with which they are familiar and have trust, rather than reaching out to new partners, authors added.

Zhu's three key takeaways for skilled nursing operators:

Payment really matters. Hospitals have been “really conscientiously and in a very collective manner reorganizing the way that they are thinking about post-acute care, and specifically trying to save costs, along those lines.” The payment structure is having a distinct effect on hospitals' behavior.

The extent to which these practices have been disseminated is unclear. Some of the things hospitals are doing have “enormous implications” for skilled nursing facilities. Hospitals are really trying to move away from SNF use, particularly for joint replacement patients. They are trying to then integrate and coordinate care with skilled nursing facilities through a variety of different structures.

There's uncertainty over what the ultimate implications are for SNFs. There is a question of what sorts of pressures SNFs will face, given these hospital practices.

“SNFs are not only under heavy pressure to work more closely with hospitals and to compete to be the desired referral partner,” Zhu told McKnights, “but they're also facing downward referral pressures as hospitals try to send their patients, more and more frequently, home.” 

Future research may expand on how nursing homes are responding to this trend. 

The Future of Home Care

Houser, Ari, "The Future of Home Care," CSA Journal (Vol.1, 2018) pp. 33-37.

Researchers find Alzheimer's Threat Persistent Regardless of Age; Average Survival Confirmed as 6 Years

According to an article published in McKnight's Long Term Care News, first-ever studies are bringing new revelations about Alzheimer's Disease.  The studies were released as the Alzheimer's Association hosts its 2018 International Conference in Chicago. Among the findings: Dementia survival time is short, regardless of the age at onset.

Aiming to better understand survival times of those diagnosed at a relatively young age, Amsterdam researchers poured over data for some 4,500 early-onset dementia patients in one memory clinic. They found that median survival time, across all age groups, was six years, hardly different from those older than 65.

These findings suggest that, despite all efforts and despite being younger and perhaps physically "‘healthier" than older people, survival time in people with young-onset dementia is not greater and  has not improved since 2000

Another study, of dementia data from 11 countries tied to more than 4,100 ages 95-110 found that prevalence of the disease increased with age in all societies.  On the other hand, though, the risk for dementia and cognitive impairment varied “significantly” from country to country, “suggesting cultural and lifestyle factors play a role in remaining physically and cognitively health with age.  Those with higher levels of education, for one, expressed a lower prevalence of dementia than those with fewer years of education.

In yet another study, researchers from the University of California-San Francisco announced this week that the dementia rate of lesbian, gay and bisexual older adults was about 7.4%, compared to about 10% for the general population, according to study results. It was the first dementia prevalence data from a large population of LGB older adults and examined data from some 3,700 such individuals over age 60. 

The association also announced on Sunday that it is establishing the first-ever Dementia Care Provider Roundtable, as a means to gather thought leaders from across the U.S. to find ways to better treat the disease.  The group, which consists of key players in the skilled nursing and assisted living fields, Genesis HealthCare and HCR Manor Care among them, will meet for the first time Thursday, the last day of the five-day conference.

Three Surprises to Watch Out for When Paying for Long Term Care

Chris Orestis, executive vice president of GWG Life, has penned an excellent article for The Independent: 

"More than 70 percent of Americans over the age of 65 will need long-term health care services, according to the U.S. Department of Health and Human Services. Yet, according to the Employee Benefit Research Institute, only 13 percent of those who received professional home health care had long-term insurance policies, which can protect seniors from high out-of-pocket costs.

There is a wide gap of people without long-term care insurance, or LTCI, and some of the alternatives carry little-known laws and legal liabilities that can pose  problem to the care recipient and their families.

The growing long-term care funding crisis has brought lawsuits and mandated claw-back actions against families in attempts to recover monies spent on long-term care. There is a growing need for consumers to consider all their available financial options to fund long-term care, and that can include selling a life insurance policy.

Often the weight for long-term care falls on the family, and they need to avoid a financial surprise that can come late in life for their loved ones.

There are three surprises to watch out for when paying for long-term care and key things people should know about alternative ways of paying for it as well as the possible problems those can present down the road.

States can sue for Medicaid recovery of LTC

Many families assume that once a senior is approved for Medicaid coverage of long-term care, the only thing left to worry about is maintaining financial and functional eligibility. You’ve proven that a loved one cannot afford the level of care he or she requires, but that doesn’t mean there isn’t anything left to worry about in terms of covering and repaying costs. The Omnibus Budget Reconciliation Act of 1993 requires states to implement a Medicaid estate-recovery program, which allows states to sue families via probate court to recover Medicaid dollars spent on a family member’s long-term care. A report by the Office of the Inspector General showed that Medicaid, the primary source of long-term coverage, recovers hundreds of millions of dollars from families every year. But as budget pressures on states increase, estate-recovery actions are likely to become even more aggressive.

Watch out for withheld information on life insurance

Selling or borrowing against a life insurance policy in the secondary market, a process called a life settlement, is a way to help people find alternative funding sources for long-term care. A number of states have passed legislation mandating consumer disclosure about the secondary market before their policies ill be allowed to lapse.

Be aware of filial responsibility laws

These impose a duty upon adult children for the support of their impoverished parents and can be extended to other relatives. These laws can include criminal penalties for adult children or close relatives who fail to provide for family members when challenged to do so. Attorneys for nursing homes are testing the laws by filing lawsuits on behalf of indigent parents to recover funds. Currently, 28 states [including Ohio]  and Puerto Rico have filial responsibility laws in place."

Proper estate and financial planning, and Aging in Place Planning in particular, demands consideration of  long term care financing opportunities, and avoidance of adverse consequences like those discussed in the article.   

Trump Administration deploys Medicaid Scorecard

In June, the Trump administration embarked on a basic change to Medicaid that for the first time evaluates states based on the health of millions of Americans and the services they use through the vast public insurance program for the poor.  Centers for Medicare and Medicaid Services CMS), deployed a “scorecard” that compiles and publicizes data from states for both Medicaid and the Children’s Health Insurance Program (CHIP), a companion for youngsters in working-class families.

This first scorecard includes state-by-state information showing that, on average, just over half the women on Medicaid are getting care while they are pregnant and after giving birth. Only three in five babies get checkups during their first 15 months, and less than half of children and teenagers have preventive dental visits.These and other measures show wide variations among states, though the initial version does not explicitly rank them. The scorecard also makes public for the first time measures of governments’ performance, such as how long both state and federal health officials take when states request “waivers” to deviate from Medicaid’s ordinary rules.

The Trump administration did not initially attach any consequences to how states make out, and indeed has declined to "rank" states.  That could change over the next few years as CMS refines and adds to the scorecard and members of Congress assess what it shows.  

The Trump Administration, through Seema Verma, head of CMS, explained that the scorecard is intended to initiate a conversation about health outcomes.  Medicaid pays for roughly half the nation’s births, but there is no data or discussion how or why states vary in birth outcomes.

The scorecard is part of a fundamental recalibration of the power relationship in Medicaid between the federal government and states. Since the program was created in 1965 as part of Lyndon Johnson’s War on Poverty, both have shared responsibility for paying for and defining the eligibility and benefits.  Medicaid now covers more than 67 million individuals, while CHIP covers nearly 6.5 million.

In the Trump era, federal health officials have been eager to give states more flexibility over Medicaid’s rules and benefits. Most significantly, the administration told states this year that it will allow them to require people to work or participate in other forms of “community engagement” to qualify for the program.

Such flexibility must be accompanied by heightened federal efforts to keep tabs on how well each state’s Medicaid program is functioning. Verma has said that “With all the flexibility must come accountability. We must be honest with ourselves and honest with our stakeholders . . . about how well we are doing.”

The scorecard’s initial information is based on states that voluntarily report a series of measures about the health of their Medicaid and CHIP enrollees. It shows, for instance, that the percentage of adults on Medicaid with high blood pressure under control as of 2016 varied from 26 percent in Louisiana to 72 percent in Rhode Island. The percentage of children ages 3 to 6 on Medicaid and CHIP who were getting adequate doctors’ care varied from 48 percent in Alaska and Idaho to 86 percent in Massachusetts.

Verma did not specify what additional information will be in later scorecards, but she said federal officials might be interested in how many people on Medicaid are working or volunteering, regardless of whether a state has imposed work requirements in its program.