Home Health Care Staff Shortages Threaten Health- Frustrates Aging in Place

This Blog has reported the threat staffing shortages pose to the long-term institutional care industry, its residents, and its patients.  Staffing shortages in the home health care industry present similar threats, both to the industry and to actual and prospective customers.  

There is a legal maxim that "Justice Delayed is Justice Denied."  In the long-term care and the health care industry there is no simple maxim that  warns that "freedom delayed is freedom denied," but there should be.  A shortage of home health care workers means that some seniors may be unable to safely return to their homes, and may, instead, be forced into institutional care alternatives otherwise avoidable.  This may seem an anomalous result, but it is real.  Seniors are transferred to institutions that are woefully understaffed every day.  

There is no compromise possible, however, for a family seeking return of their mother or father to a home when they cannot demonstrate adequate and sufficient support services.  The systemic choice is clear; it is unacceptable for a senior to be at risk in their own home, but acceptable if that risk is institutional.  The Trump Administration learned, for example, that there were nursing homes opened and operating, without a nurse.  Medicare did not, and to this day, does not prohibit the transfer of a patient from a hospital to a poorly staffed nursing home or assisted living facility!     

Aging in Place Planning is specifically designed to reduce the risk of unnecessary and avoidable institutional care.  Unfortunately, many seniors may need home health care workers for short periods of time following acute needs or hospitalizations in order to rehabilitate safely at home.  "Freedom," may be denied these seniors if there is no choice but institutional care.   

Kaiser Health News, published a story about the on-going shortage, entitled, "Desperate for Home Care, Seniors Often Wait Months With Workers in Short Supply."  Using Maine as an example, the article explains:

"The Maine home-based care program, which helps....more than 800 in the state, has a waitlist 925 people long; those applicants sometimes lack help for months or years, according to officials in Maine, which has the country’s oldest population. This leaves many people at an increased risk of falls or not getting medical care and other dangers.  The problem is simple: Here and in much of the rest of the country there are too few workers. Yet, the solution is anything but easy."

Katie Smith Sloan , CEO of Leading Age, which represents nonprofit aging services providers, told Kaiser that the workforce shortage is a nationwide dilemma:

 “Millions of older adults are unable to access the affordable care and services that they so desperately need,” she said at a recent press event. State and federal reimbursement rates to elder care agencies are inadequate to cover the cost of quality care and services or to pay a living wage to caregivers."

This shortage was not unexpected.  Kaiser reported that "[f]or at least 20 years, national experts have warned about the dire consequences of a shortage of nursing assistants and home aides as tens of millions of baby boomers hit their senior years." President Biden even included funding for home and community-based care in the infrastructure bill ("human infrastructure").

And here we are. 

Picture Credit: Photo 19608638 / Help Wanted © Martinmark | Dreamstime.com